The finale of Presumed Innocent on Apple TV+ packs a punch with its long-awaited revelations and courtroom drama. This final episode, "The Verdict," delivers the truth behind Carolyn Polhemus' murder, tying up loose ends with both suspense and emotional depth.
The heart of the series lies in Rusty Sabich's intense struggle to clear his name. Jake Gyllenhaal's portrayal of Rusty is gripping, oscillating between a desperate man on the brink and a sharp, determined lawyer. His performance anchors the episode, especially in the courtroom scenes where his battle with Deputy District Attorney Tommy Molto (played by Peter Sarsgaard) reaches a boiling point. Their professional rivalry and personal animosity drive the tension, making each interaction electric.
The courtroom scenes are the highlight, showcasing David E. Kelley's strength in crafting legal drama. The back-and-forth legal arguments, the strategic plays, and the emotional stakes are all portrayed with a precision that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. The narrative carefully builds up to the final verdict, ensuring the suspense is maintained until the last moment.
However, the episode isn't without its flaws. The series has struggled with character development outside the courtroom, and this is evident in the finale. Carolyn Polhemus remains an enigma, her character is never fully fleshed out, which diminishes the emotional impact of the case's resolution. We see her mostly through Rusty's perspective, which fails to provide a comprehensive view of her life and motives. This lack of depth in Carolyn's character makes it hard for the audience to form a strong emotional connection to her.
The familial and personal drama involving Rusty and his wife Barbara (Ruth Negga) occasionally feels repetitive and overly melodramatic. While Negga's performance is commendable, the subplot of Barbara's exploration of romance outside her marriage feels somewhat disconnected from the main narrative thread. These moments can drag the pacing, detracting from the episode's otherwise high-stakes atmosphere.
Despite these issues, "The Verdict" succeeds in maintaining the core mystery's intrigue. The show does an excellent job of keeping viewers guessing about Rusty's innocence. Even as incriminating details are revealed, the uncertainty remains, creating a compelling tension. The final moments, where the truth is laid bare, are both satisfying and thought-provoking, leaving a lasting impact.
In conclusion, the finale of *Presumed Innocent* offers a robust and engaging end to the series. It excels in its courtroom drama and the complex portrayal of Rusty Sabich's fight for justice. While some character development issues persist, they do not overshadow the episode's strengths. "The Verdict" is a fitting conclusion that balances suspense, legal intricacies, and emotional depth, making it a must-watch for fans of legal thrillers.
Final Score - [7/10]