Apple TV+ ‘Presumed Innocent’ Episode 3 Review - New Evidence and Old Wounds

"Presumed Innocent," the legal drama series on Apple TV+, continues to deliver its gripping narrative with Episode 3, titled "Discovery," diving deeper into the intricate web of lies, deception, and moral ambiguity that defines the show's core. This episode effectively balances the intense courtroom drama with the personal turmoil of its characters, although it occasionally stumbles in pacing and character development.

Episode 3 thrusts viewers further into the chaos surrounding Rusty Sabich (Jake Gyllenhaal), a deputy prosecutor accused of murdering his colleague and former lover, Carolyn Polhemus (Renate Reinsve). The episode opens with Rusty grappling with the mounting evidence against him and his deteriorating relationship with his wife, Barbara (Ruth Negga). As the courtroom scenes unfold, we witness a fierce battle of wits between Rusty’s defense team and the prosecution, led by Tommy Molto (Peter Sarsgaard).

The episode meticulously details the courtroom strategies employed by both sides, highlighting the complexities of the legal system and the personal vendettas driving the case. Rusty's interactions with his colleagues and the unraveling of his professional life add layers of tension, making it clear that the stakes are not just legal but deeply personal.

One of the standout aspects of Episode 3 is its commitment to the legal drama genre. The courtroom scenes are particularly compelling, showcasing the meticulous preparation and strategic maneuvers of the attorneys involved. The dialogue is sharp and realistic, capturing the essence of high-stakes legal battles. The tension between Rusty and Tommy Molto is palpable, adding a visceral edge to their exchanges.

Visually, "Discovery" maintains the series' polished aesthetic. The direction by Anne Sewitsky and Greg Yaitanes ensures that the tension is palpable, whether in the courtroom or in Rusty's personal moments. The cinematography and use of lighting effectively enhance the mood, adding depth to the storytelling.

However, the episode does falter when it shifts focus to Rusty's personal life. The scenes depicting his strained marriage and interactions with his children feel somewhat repetitive and lack the same intensity as the courtroom drama. While these moments are crucial for understanding Rusty's character and motivations, they could benefit from more nuanced writing to avoid the soap opera feel that sometimes creeps in.

The character of Carolyn Polhemus remains enigmatic, primarily seen through flashbacks and Rusty's perspective. This approach makes it difficult to fully empathize with her, as she feels more like a plot device than a fully realized character. The lack of depth in her portrayal diminishes the emotional impact of the murder investigation, leaving viewers somewhat detached from the central mystery.

Despite these criticisms, Episode 3 excels in maintaining the show's overall suspense and intrigue. The cliffhanger at the end of the episode is particularly effective, ensuring that viewers remain invested in the unfolding drama. The series' strength lies in its ability to keep the audience guessing about Rusty's innocence, a feat that is impressively sustained through well-timed reveals and plot twists.

The performances in Episode 3 are consistently strong. Jake Gyllenhaal delivers a nuanced portrayal of Rusty Sabich, capturing the character's vulnerability and desperation. Ruth Negga shines as Barbara Sabich, bringing a quiet intensity to her role that contrasts with Rusty's more overt emotional turmoil. Peter Sarsgaard’s portrayal of Tommy Molto adds a layer of complexity to the prosecution, making him more than just a one-dimensional antagonist.

Episode 3 of "Presumed Innocent" reinforces the show's strengths in legal drama and character-driven storytelling, even as it struggles with some aspects of pacing and character development. The courtroom scenes are riveting, and the central mystery remains engaging, but the personal subplots need more depth to match the intensity of the legal proceedings.

Overall, this episode is a solid addition to the series, keeping viewers hooked with its intricate plot and strong performances. While there are areas that could be improved, particularly in the portrayal of secondary characters and the pacing of personal storylines, "Presumed Innocent" continues to be a compelling watch for fans of legal dramas and suspenseful storytelling.

Final Score - [7/10]