‘Bad Fish’ (2024) Movie Review - Not All Mermaids are Fairies

Bad Fish (2024), directed and written by Brad Douglas, is a gripping thriller that merges folklore with modern horror elements. Set in the small coastal town of Brookings, Oregon, the film centers on John Burton, a marine biologist who is called in to investigate a series of deadly attacks on local fishermen. As the bodies pile up, what begins as a rational scientific investigation morphs into a horrifying realization: the killer is not a human, but a mermaid.

The premise of Bad Fish might seem absurd on the surface, but Douglas takes a fresh approach to the myth of the mermaid, transforming it into something both beautiful and terrifying. The mermaid in question is a deadly creature driven by primal instincts, desperate to find a mate so she can have children—or else she will perish. This chilling twist on the traditional image of mermaids as benevolent, mythical creatures adds a layer of complexity to the narrative.

The movie thrives on its atmospheric tension and small-town setting. The coastal landscape of Oregon, with its mist-covered shores and desolate beaches, serves as the perfect backdrop for the unfolding horror. The cinematography effectively captures the eerie beauty of the ocean while maintaining a sense of dread as the protagonist, John Burton, dives deeper into the town’s dark secrets.

Jonny Lee, in the role of John Burton, delivers a strong performance as a man of science whose beliefs are shattered by the supernatural events he encounters. Burton’s character arc is compelling, as his rational mindset is increasingly challenged by the mounting evidence of the mermaid’s existence. Abby Wathen, who plays Abby Brand, the daughter of one of the victims, adds emotional depth to the story. Her personal quest for answers and her partnership with Burton drives the narrative forward, creating a tense dynamic as they unravel the mystery together.

The supporting cast also contributes to the film's eerie charm. Marlyn Mason, as Abby’s grandmother Phyllis, serves as the town historian, offering cryptic insights into the legend of the mermaid. Mark Schneider as Skip Porter, a skeptical fisherman, brings a grounded perspective, while Scott Ford’s portrayal of Ben Burns, a local with hidden knowledge of the curse, adds to the overall mystery.

The film’s antagonist, the mermaid played by Abby Wathen, is a standout. Her portrayal is both stunning and terrifying, embodying the dual nature of the creature—beautiful yet deadly. The mermaid's pursuit of a mate adds urgency and primal fear to the plot, as her desperation leads to increasingly violent attacks.

While Bad Fish could have easily veered into campy territory, it is saved by its strong direction and committed performance. The tension builds steadily throughout the film, culminating in a suspenseful and satisfying climax. Douglas manages to balance the more fantastical elements of the story with genuine moments of horror, making this film a must-see for fans of creature features and thriller enthusiasts alike.

In conclusion, Bad Fish is a well-crafted thriller that defies expectations. Its unique blend of horror, folklore, and suspense makes it a standout film in the genre, proving that even the most outlandish premises can be transformed into something gripping and memorable when handled with care.

Final Score- [7/10]
Reviewed by - Neerja Choudhuri
Follow @NeerjaCH on Twitter
Publisher at Midgard Times