‘Untold: Sign Stealer’ Netflix Review - Beyond What the Eyes See

"Sign Stealer," the latest documentary from Netflix’s "Untold" series, delves deep into the murky underworld of college football, where trickery, deceit, and internet-fueled chaos collide. The documentary paints a vivid picture of a secretive subculture filled with dirty plays, shadowy figures, and a barrage of viral memes.

At the center of the story is Connor Stalions, a notorious figure in Michigan's infamous sign-stealing scandal. Through a series of cinematic shots, the documentary follows Stalions as he roams down alleyways and sits brooding in empty parking lots, evoking a sense of isolation and intrigue. These visuals capture the eerie atmosphere of a spy thriller, setting the stage for the film’s portrayal of the covert tactics that grip the sport.

For those of you who don’t know who Stalions is or what he did, here is some background story: Connor Stalions was a relatively unknown figure in Michigan's football staff, tasked with the seemingly routine yet crucial role of decoding the signals of opposing teams—a common and perfectly legal practice in college football. However, Stalions pushed beyond the conventional methods of signal deciphering, allegedly crossing ethical boundaries and venturing into a realm of espionage that shook the foundations of the sport. Reports claim Stalions didn't just analyze signals from the sidelines or review game footage like most staffers. Instead, he allegedly orchestrated an elaborate scheme to gather intelligence, including using cell phone video to record teams' signals from the stands— an act that violates both the spirit and the rules of fair play. His audacity didn’t stop there. In what seems straight out of a spy novel, Stalions reportedly disguised himself and infiltrated the Central Michigan sideline during a game against Michigan State, blending in among the coaches and players to observe their signals up close. This brazen approach caught the attention of the NCAA, triggering an investigation that cast a shadow over Michigan's otherwise stellar 2023 season. Despite their pursuit of a national championship, the allegations surrounding Stalions left a permanent mark on the team's achievements. What was shaping up to be a season of glory for Michigan quickly became mired in controversy, as the sign-stealing scandal called into question the integrity of their success, sparking widespread debate across the college football world.

In addition to Stalions, the film introduces colorful characters from the wider football landscape. Barstool Sports' outspoken founder Dave Portnoy makes an appearance, bringing his signature irreverence to the narrative.

Stalions' legal team has argued that he technically didn’t violate the in-person scouting rule, as he wasn’t physically present at the games in question. Instead, his friends and family members—neither officially scouts nor employed by the team—were the ones in attendance. According to his defense, this distinction keeps Stalions within the letter of the law, even if the spirit may be questionable.

The documentary blends elements of espionage and dark comedy, often feeling like a Coen brothers film, as it explores the absurd lengths individuals will go to gain an edge in the high-stakes world of college football. With its mix of suspense, wit, and internet culture, "Sign Stealer" offers a unique look into the sport’s shadier corners, where every move is a calculated game of deception.

Final Score- [7/10]
Reviewed by - Neerja Choudhuri
Follow @NeerjaCH on Twitter
Publisher at Midgard Times