‘You Would Do It Too’ Apple TV+ Series Review - A Dark and Twisty Whodunit Set in Barcelona

“You Would Do It Too” (Tú También Lo Harías) dives headfirst into the chaotic world of human perception and truth-twisting, framed by an intense and gritty robbery gone wrong. It starts off with what feels like a simple crime thriller but quickly morphs into a deeper psychological maze, where everyone has a version of the truth, and no one can be trusted.

The show opens with the aftermath of a bus heist that ends in three robbers being shot dead, but what follows is not your typical police investigation. The twist? The story is less about what happened and more about why it happened. Six witnesses are left behind, each holding onto their own version of events, and the detectives must wade through their conflicting stories to piece together the truth before time runs out.

The premise, though familiar, is effectively executed. A robbery, a cover-up, unreliable witnesses—classic ingredients for suspense. What makes “You Would Do It Too” interesting is how it tackles the human element. Each of the six witnesses has something to hide, and the show teases out their secrets slowly, keeping you hooked. The pacing is fast, with the investigation feeling like a high-stakes game where the detectives are former lovers—adding yet another layer of complexity to the mix. Their tense personal history doesn’t overshadow the story but adds a layer of emotional conflict that makes their quest for the truth even more fraught.

Ana Polvorosa and Michelle Jenner lead the cast, and their performances are compelling. Polvorosa, in particular, brings a simmering intensity to her role, playing a woman caught between truth and self-preservation. The way the characters are drawn feels refreshing for a thriller; they're neither clear-cut heroes nor villains, but flawed individuals, which raises the stakes and makes the story unpredictable.

The storytelling in "You Would Do It Too" is engaging but at times feels like it’s trying to juggle too many things at once. The narrative, though sharp, can occasionally get muddled as it leans into the psychological aspects of trauma, guilt, and moral ambiguity. There are moments when you wonder if the show is biting off more than it can chew—trying to be a social commentary, psychological study, and tense crime thriller all at the same time. Sometimes, this multi-layered approach works, but at other times, it feels like the series loses focus.

Visually, the show doesn’t hold back in portraying the grittiness of urban Barcelona. The cinematography is bleak and atmospheric, adding to the show’s overall feeling of tension and unease. It’s shot in a way that makes you feel like you’re peeking into something you shouldn’t be seeing, heightening the suspense. The city itself becomes a character, with its dark alleyways and crowded spaces, reflecting the chaotic moral landscape of the characters.

The strength of “You Would Do It Too” lies in how it plays with your expectations. Just when you think you’ve figured it out, the show throws in a curveball. It’s a series that asks uncomfortable questions about morality: How far would you go to protect yourself? At what point does self-preservation become criminal? The show wants you to wrestle with these dilemmas, but it doesn’t necessarily give you the space to breathe and think about them, because the next twist is always just around the corner.

That said, the show isn’t without its drawbacks. As thrilling as the premise is, there are moments where the writing feels a bit too contrived, especially when the characters are clearly withholding information just to build suspense. This kind of plot manipulation can pull you out of the story. Also, the back-and-forth between the detectives’ romantic past and the current investigation can feel forced at times. It’s not that their relationship isn’t interesting, but it sometimes detracts from the intensity of the investigation, adding a melodramatic layer that doesn’t always feel necessary.

Still, despite these occasional stumbles, the series manages to stay captivating. The constant back-and-forth between the detectives and the witnesses keeps you guessing, and just when you think you’ve got it all figured out, the rug is pulled from under you. The layered narrative is tricky but intriguing, and the performances of the main cast help elevate the more convoluted moments of the script.

Regarding rewatchability, “You Would Do It Too” probably won’t stand up to multiple viewings once the mystery is unraveled, but for a first watch, it’s a ride worth taking. It’s not a groundbreaking show, but it’s a solid thriller that keeps you on edge with its moral questions and constant twists. The show's creators, David Victori, and Jordi Vallejo, have crafted a tense atmosphere that complements the show's thematic focus on truth and deception, though sometimes it leans too heavily into its tricks without delivering full emotional payoffs.

Ultimately, “You Would Do It Too” is a series that thrives on its unpredictability and moral murkiness. It leaves you wondering what you would do in the character’s shoes, which is exactly the kind of uncomfortable, thought-provoking tension you want from a thriller. Sure, it’s not perfect—some twists feel a bit too convenient, and the pacing occasionally stumbles—but it’s undeniably engaging and entertaining. And if you enjoy your thrillers with a side of moral ambiguity and flawed characters, this one’s worth the watch.

For anyone looking for a mystery that’s equal parts whodunit and psychological drama, “You Would Do It Too” scratches that itch, while also making you think twice about how far you’d go to protect your own secrets.

Final Score- [6/10]
Reviewed by - Anjali Sharma
Follow @AnjaliS54769166 on Twitter
Publisher at Midgard Times
Note: All 8 episodes are screened for this review.
Premiere Date: October 30, 2024, on Apple TV+ with the first two episodes followed by a new episode every Wednesday.