Apple TV+ ‘Before’ Episode 5 Review - The Ties that Bind Eli and Noah’s Journey

In the fifth episode of Before, titled "Folie à Deux," the series dives deeper into the intricate dynamics between Eli and Noah. The episode masterfully balances a psychological thriller atmosphere with moments of warmth and vulnerability, showcasing the complexity of Eli's emotional journey as he navigates his own grief and his attempts to help Noah.

The narrative unfolds with Eli, played by Billy Crystal, becoming increasingly fascinated—and perhaps obsessed—by Noah, a boy who seems to embody Eli's unresolved past. Their interactions are tense yet tender, reflecting a nuanced exploration of how trauma can manifest in relationships. Crystal’s performance shines here; he brings a depth of understanding to Eli, whose kindness is laced with an underlying desperation to heal both himself and Noah. This episode brilliantly captures the essence of human connection in the face of shared pain.

Visually, the episode maintains the show's signature moody aesthetic, using shadow and light to convey emotional depth. The cinematography creates a palpable tension, especially in scenes where Eli's past and present collide. The use of close-ups during emotional exchanges allows viewers to feel the weight of Eli's internal struggles, making the experience immersive. The direction by Adam Bernstein skillfully orchestrates these moments, ensuring that the pacing keeps viewers on edge, yet engaged.

One of the highlights of "Folie à Deux" is its exploration of the theme of duality—both in terms of mental health and interpersonal relationships. The episode delves into the concept of shared delusions and how they can form powerful bonds between individuals. The title itself suggests a deep connection, one that may not always be healthy, reflecting the complexities of Eli and Noah's relationship. This psychological element adds an intriguing layer to the storyline, making it both compelling and thought-provoking.

However, while the episode excels in many areas, it does have some shortcomings. At times, the pacing felt uneven, particularly in the middle sequences where the tension momentarily waned. There were moments when the narrative seemed to lose focus, resulting in a slight drag that could test the patience of viewers. Additionally, while the emotional depth is commendable, certain plot points felt a bit predictable, perhaps relying on established tropes of the genre. A more unexpected twist could have heightened the dramatic stakes and kept viewers on their toes.

Despite these minor flaws, character development remains a strong suit of the series. Judith Light's portrayal of Eli's late wife, Lynn, continues to resonate throughout, weaving her presence into Eli's journey of healing. The flashbacks and memories of their time together serve not just as a reminder of what Eli has lost but also as a catalyst for his growth and understanding. This layered storytelling enhances the emotional weight of the episode, allowing for poignant reflections on love, loss, and the power of memories.

The episode culminates in a powerful climax that forces Eli to confront his own demons while also recognizing the importance of letting go. The final scenes are a blend of catharsis and tension, leaving viewers eager for the next installment. It’s a testament to the show's ability to weave complex emotions with a sense of urgency, engaging audiences in a way that feels both satisfying and haunting.

In conclusion, "Folie à Deux" is a compelling addition to Before, successfully navigating the murky waters of grief, healing, and the intricacies of human connection. While it occasionally stumbles in pacing and predictability, the strong performances, particularly from Billy Crystal, and the thoughtful exploration of its themes more than compensate. This episode deepens our understanding of the characters and leaves us with lingering questions about trauma and the bonds we form in its presence. As we look ahead to the next episode, one can't help but feel excited to see where Eli and Noah's journey will lead, and what revelations await them.

Final Score- [6.5/10]