Apple TV+ ‘Criminal Record’ Episode 4 Review - Unraveling Threads, Unsettled Alliances

In the fourth riveting installment of "Criminal Record," aptly titled "Protected," the series navigates a labyrinth of investigations, alliances, and simmering tension. As the layers of deception are peeled back, the characters find themselves entwined in a complex dance of crime, loyalty, and the elusive pursuit of truth.

The episode kicks off with a press conference, thrusting the audience into the harsh aftermath of Isaac's tragic shooting. Hegarty, embodied by the stalwart Peter Capaldi, engages in a probing dialogue with the suspect, Jason. His initial confession, however, leaves Hegarty unconvinced, setting the stage for a deeper exploration into the murky waters of coercion and deceit.

One of the strengths of this episode lies in its meticulous examination of Hegarty's involvement in the investigation surrounding Adelaide's murder, as he recounts the story to Patrick, Adelaide's son. The nuanced portrayal of Hegarty's complex relationship with Patrick adds a layer of emotional depth to the narrative, revealing shades of paternal care juxtaposed against the shadows of suspicion.

As the plot unfolds, June pursues leads related to the mysterious Carla, a woman entangled in a web of secrecy. The narrative weaves an intricate pattern as June follows the trail of Errol's alibi, immersing herself in the Turkish connection. The breadth of Hegarty's involvement in each lead June pursues raises intriguing questions about his motives, injecting an air of suspicion that lingers like an unsolved riddle.

Yet, amidst the unfolding complexities, the episode grapples with a significant challenge – an overload of character names and information. The narrative juggles multiple threads, introducing new characters and plot points, at times leaving the audience to navigate through a dense thicket of details. This abundance of information, while integral to the overarching mystery, occasionally disrupts the fluidity of the storytelling.

The palpable tension simmering beneath the surface, unfortunately, struggles to fully manifest. Despite the high-stakes scenarios and characters teetering on the edge of danger, the dialogue and overall execution fall short of cultivating a genuine sense of threat. The potential for a heightened emotional impact is compromised, as the episode fails to build the necessary atmosphere of impending peril.

One of the episode's notable strengths lies in its exploration of Hegarty's suspiciously swift discovery of suspects. The narrative skillfully intertwines his presence in almost every lead June pursues, creating a web of intrigue that captivates the audience. This dynamic interplay between the two central characters deepens the mystery and raises questions about Hegarty's true agenda.

Nevertheless, the tension remains somewhat superficial, lacking the visceral impact that would elevate the stakes and immerse the audience in the characters' perilous journey. The dialogue, while serviceable, misses the opportunity to infuse the scenes with the urgency and gravity required to convey the imminent threats faced by the characters.

In conclusion, "Protected" stands as a chapter marked by intricate investigations, subtle character dynamics, and the relentless pursuit of truth. The episode successfully explores the enigma of Hegarty's involvement and deepens the shadows enveloping our protagonists. However, the challenge of managing an abundance of character details and the failure to fully realize the potential tension hinder the episode from reaching its zenith. As "Criminal Record" forges ahead, the audience is left eagerly anticipating the unraveling of mysteries and the looming confrontations that promise to define the series' crescendo.

Final Score- [6/10]