Apple TV+ ‘The Big Cigar’ Episode 5 Review - Friendships and Frictions

Episode 5 of Apple TV+’s "The Big Cigar," titled “Lost Paradise,” is a compelling mix of tension, tragedy, and transformation. Directed by Tiffany Johnson, this episode dives deeper into the intricate web of alliances and conflicts that define Huey P. Newton’s escape to Cuba. As someone who has been following this series closely, I found this episode to be a pivotal point that balances the narrative's complexity with emotional depth.

In “Lost Paradise,” we see Clark, the relentless FBI agent, ramp up pressure on the Mexican government, creating a more perilous situation for Huey and his allies. This escalating tension sets a gripping tone for the episode. The stakes are higher than ever, and you can feel the walls closing in around Huey.

A significant, heart-wrenching moment in this episode is the tragedy that strikes Bert Schneider. Alessandro Nivola’s portrayal of Bert is touching, capturing the profound impact of the loss on the group’s morale. This event not only shakes Huey but also highlights the vulnerabilities of even the most determined revolutionaries. It’s a stark reminder that their journey is fraught with danger and personal sacrifice.

Meanwhile, Huey receives life-changing news that adds another layer to his already complicated life. André Holland, as Huey, continues to deliver a magnetic performance, embodying the character’s charisma and inner turmoil. The news propels Huey into a state of reflection and determination, though it’s clear that his path is anything but straightforward.
The roadblock Huey encounters towards the end of the episode is a testament to the show’s ability to maintain suspense. Just when it seems like there might be a moment of respite, another challenge looms large. This keeps the audience on edge, invested in Huey’s fate.

One of the strengths of “Lost Paradise” is its ability to blend personal moments with the broader political narrative. The interactions between Huey and Bobby Seale, and the nuanced portrayal of their strained friendship, add emotional weight to the story. The show does a commendable job of humanizing these historical figures, making their struggles and triumphs feel personal and relatable.

However, the episode isn’t without its flaws. At times, the narrative can feel a bit disjointed, as it tries to juggle multiple plotlines. Some scenes transition abruptly, which can momentarily disrupt the flow of the story. Additionally, while the episode excels in building tension, it occasionally leans too heavily on dramatic tropes, making certain moments feel predictable.

Despite these minor issues, “Lost Paradise” is a strong addition to "The Big Cigar." The performances are consistently excellent, and the direction effectively captures the era’s atmosphere. The episode’s balance of action, emotion, and historical context makes it both engaging and thought-provoking.

The visual and auditory elements also deserve praise. The period-appropriate settings and costumes immerse the viewer in the 1970s, while the soundtrack enhances the emotional resonance of key scenes. These production values add richness to the viewing experience, making the historical drama feel vibrant and authentic.

In terms of character development, this episode allows us to see different facets of Huey. His moments of vulnerability, anger, and determination are portrayed with depth and nuance. The supporting characters, too, are given moments to shine, with their own struggles and motivations coming to the forefront. This multi-dimensional portrayal helps in creating a more comprehensive understanding of the narrative’s stakes.

The underlying themes of loyalty, sacrifice, and resilience are explored with subtlety. The show avoids oversimplifying the characters’ motivations, instead presenting them as complex individuals navigating a tumultuous political landscape. This adds a layer of authenticity to the storytelling, making it more impactful.

Overall, “Lost Paradise” successfully captures the essence of "The Big Cigar." It’s an episode that combines historical intrigue with personal drama, keeping viewers engaged and emotionally invested. The minor narrative hiccups do little to detract from the overall quality of the episode. If anything, they remind us of the ambitious scope of the series and its dedication to telling a multifaceted story.

As the series approaches its conclusion, “Lost Paradise” sets the stage for what promises to be an intense and gripping finale. For viewers who have been following Huey’s journey, this episode offers both a deepening of the narrative and a tantalizing glimpse of the challenges yet to come. It’s a testament to the series’ strength that it can maintain such a high level of engagement and emotional investment.

In conclusion, “Lost Paradise” is a must-watch for fans of "The Big Cigar." It encapsulates the series’ strengths while setting up a promising trajectory for the final episodes. The blend of historical context, character-driven storytelling, and high-stakes drama makes it a standout episode in an already impressive series.

Final Score- [7.5/10]